| Player | Pos | Age | Tries | Team | Ground | Date | Match | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KJ Donald | W | 21y 190d | 1 | Australia | Murrayfield | 15 Feb 1958 | Details | |
| AJ Summons | FH | 22y 36d | 1 | Australia | Lansdowne Road | 18 Jan 1958 | Details | |
| R Phelps | W | 22y 124d | 1 | Australia | Lansdowne Road | 18 Jan 1958 | Details | |
| JE Thornett | F | 22y 322d | 1 | Australia | Murrayfield | 15 Feb 1958 | Details | |
| MS Phillips | C | 22y 335d | 1 | England | Twickenham | 1 Feb 1958 | Details | |
| M Crauste | F | 23y 246d | 1 | France | Colombes | 9 Mar 1958 | Details | |
| GD Stevenson | C | 24y 261d | 1 | Scotland | Murrayfield | 15 Feb 1958 | Details | |
| H Rancoule | W | 25y 31d | 1 | France | Colombes | 9 Mar 1958 | Details | |
| AR Dawson | H | 25y 227d | 1 | Ireland | Lansdowne Road | 18 Jan 1958 | Details | |
| A Quaglio | P | 26y 20d | 1 | France | Colombes | 9 Mar 1958 | Details | |
| TG Weatherstone | W | 26y 233d | 1 | Scotland | Murrayfield | 15 Feb 1958 | Details | |
| JE Collins | W | 26y 353d | 1 | Wales | Cardiff | 4 Jan 1958 | Details | |
| PB Jackson | W | 27y 132d | 1 | England | Twickenham | 1 Feb 1958 | Details | |
| AR Miller | L | 28y 250d | 1 | Australia | Cardiff | 4 Jan 1958 | Details | |
| NJ Henderson | C | 29y 161d | 1 | Ireland | Lansdowne Road | 18 Jan 1958 | Details |
Only the player's first match as a tryscorer listed
| Records include the following current or recent matches: |
|
France v Australia at Colombes, Mar 9, 1958 [19-0 FT] |
|
Scotland v Australia at Murrayfield, Feb 15, 1958 [12-8 FT] |
|
England v Australia at Twickenham, Feb 1, 1958 [9-6 FT] |
