| Player | Mat | Start Date | Team | Opposition | End Date | Team | Opposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RJR O'Gara | 14* | 4 Mar 2000 | Ireland | v Italy | 25 Feb 2012 | Ireland | v Italy |
| BG O'Driscoll | 13 | 4 Mar 2000 | Ireland | v Italy | 2 Oct 2011 | Ireland | v Italy |
| JJ Hayes | 12* | 4 Mar 2000 | Ireland | v Italy | 6 Feb 2010 | Ireland | v Italy |
| GW D'Arcy | 12* | 20 Mar 2004 | Ireland | v Italy | 8 Mar 2014 | Ireland | v Italy |
| PJ O'Connell | 12* | 23 Mar 2002 | Ireland | v Italy | 4 Oct 2015 | Ireland | v Italy |
| PA Stringer | 11* | 4 Mar 2000 | Ireland | v Italy | 15 Feb 2009 | Ireland | v Italy |
| DF O'Callaghan | 11* | 30 Aug 2003 | Ireland | v Italy | 25 Feb 2012 | Ireland | v Italy |
| GT Dempsey | 10* | 10 Apr 1999 | Ireland | v Italy | 2 Feb 2008 | Ireland | v Italy |
| ME O'Kelly | 10* | 4 Mar 2000 | Ireland | v Italy | 15 Feb 2009 | Ireland | v Italy |
| DM Hartley | 10* | 7 Feb 2009 | England | v Italy | 4 Feb 2018 | England | v Italy |
| A Domenech | 9* | 24 Apr 1954 | France | v Italy | 14 Apr 1963 | France | v Italy |
| M Crauste | 9* | 7 Apr 1958 | France | v Italy | 9 Apr 1966 | France | v Italy |
| J Leonard | 9* | 8 Oct 1991 | England | v Italy | 15 Feb 2004 | England | v Italy |
| MJS Dawson | 9* | 22 Nov 1998 | England | v Italy | 11 Feb 2006 | England | v Italy |
| SH Easterby | 9* | 4 Mar 2000 | Ireland | v Italy | 2 Feb 2008 | Ireland | v Italy |
| MJ Horan | 9* | 22 Feb 2003 | Ireland | v Italy | 15 Feb 2009 | Ireland | v Italy |
| JP Wilkinson | 9* | 2 Oct 1999 | England | v Italy | 12 Feb 2011 | England | v Italy |
| JH Roberts | 9* | 14 Mar 2009 | Wales | v Italy | 5 Feb 2017 | Wales | v Italy |
| ST Moore | 9* | 25 Jun 2005 | Australia | v Italy | 24 Jun 2017 | Australia | v Italy |
| DR Cole | 9* | 14 Feb 2010 | England | v Italy | 9 Mar 2019 | England | v Italy |
| JC McGrath | 9* | 8 Mar 2014 | Ireland | v Italy | 10 Aug 2019 | Ireland | v Italy |
| LBN Dallaglio | 8* | 23 Nov 1996 | England | v Italy | 11 Feb 2006 | England | v Italy |
| F Pelous | 8* | 18 Oct 1997 | France | v Italy | 25 Feb 2006 | France | v Italy |
| DJ Grewcock | 8* | 2 Oct 1999 | England | v Italy | 10 Feb 2007 | England | v Italy |
| GEA Murphy | 8* | 22 Feb 2003 | Ireland | v Italy | 15 Feb 2009 | Ireland | v Italy |
| DP Wallace | 8* | 3 Feb 2001 | Ireland | v Italy | 5 Feb 2011 | Ireland | v Italy |
| SD Shaw | 8* | 23 Nov 1996 | England | v Italy | 12 Feb 2011 | England | v Italy |
| DP Leamy | 8* | 6 Feb 2005 | Ireland | v Italy | 2 Oct 2011 | Ireland | v Italy |
| RD Best | 8 | 17 Mar 2007 | Ireland | v Italy | 25 Feb 2012 | Ireland | v Italy |
| WM Phillips | 8* | 11 Mar 2006 | Wales | v Italy | 1 Feb 2014 | Wales | v Italy |
| AD Trimble | 8* | 17 Mar 2007 | Ireland | v Italy | 12 Mar 2016 | Ireland | v Italy |
| JAW Haskell | 8* | 10 Feb 2008 | England | v Italy | 26 Feb 2017 | England | v Italy |
| GP North | 8* | 10 Mar 2012 | Wales | v Italy | 11 Mar 2018 | Wales | v Italy |
| KJ Owens | 8* | 10 Mar 2012 | Wales | v Italy | 11 Mar 2018 | Wales | v Italy |
| AP Ashley-Cooper | 8* | 8 Nov 2008 | Australia | v Italy | 17 Nov 2018 | Australia | v Italy |
| AW Jones | 8* | 14 Mar 2009 | Wales | v Italy | 9 Feb 2019 | Wales | v Italy |
| JJ Sexton | 8* | 5 Feb 2011 | Ireland | v Italy | 24 Feb 2019 | Ireland | v Italy |
| BR Youngs | 8* | 12 Feb 2011 | England | v Italy | 9 Mar 2019 | England | v Italy |
| DA Toner | 8* | 8 Mar 2014 | Ireland | v Italy | 10 Aug 2019 | Ireland | v Italy |
* indicates that the sequence is ongoing/unbroken
| Records include the following current or recent matches: |
|
England v Italy at Newcastle, Sep 6, 2019 [0-0] |
|
Ireland v Italy at Lansdowne Road, Aug 10, 2019 [29-10 FT] |
|
England v Italy at Twickenham, Six Nations, Mar 9, 2019 [57-14 FT] |