| Player | Mat | Start Date | Team | Opposition | End Date | Team | Opposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TW Billups | 29 | 19 Jun 1993 | USA | v Canada | 6 Jun 1998 | USA | v Canada |
| KR Swords | 21 | 21 Apr 1985 | USA | v Japan | 27 Apr 1991 | USA | v Japan |
| KG Higgins | 16 | 21 Apr 1985 | USA | v Japan | 23 Sep 1989 | USA | v Canada |
| JP Wilkerson | 15 | 11 Oct 1991 | USA | v England | 12 Apr 1998 | USA | v Spain |
| KD Shuman | 15 | 17 May 1997 | USA | v Hong Kong | 2 Oct 1999 | USA | v Ireland |
| DW Dorsey | 14 | 1 Dec 2001 | USA | v South Africa | 23 Aug 2003 | USA | v Argentina |
| MZ Petri | 14 | 30 Sep 2007 | USA | v South Africa | 21 Nov 2009 | USA | v Uruguay |
| LM Wilfley | 13 | 10 Jun 2000 | USA | v Ireland | 31 Aug 2002 | USA | v Uruguay |
| S Paga | 13 | 6 Jun 1998 | USA | v Canada | 27 May 2004 | USA | v Canada |
| DT Hodges | 12 | 21 Sep 1996 | USA | v Uruguay | 15 Aug 1998 | USA | v Argentina |
| FT Mo'unga | 12 | 6 Jun 1998 | USA | v Canada | 27 Apr 2003 | USA | v Spain |
| M Wyatt | 12 | 23 Aug 2003 | USA | v Argentina | 4 Jun 2005 | USA | v Wales |
| MK Sika | 11 | 19 Jun 1993 | USA | v Canada | 29 Jun 1996 | USA | v Hong Kong |
| G Sucher | 11 | 6 Jun 1998 | USA | v Canada | 26 Jun 1999 | USA | v Samoa |
| A Parker | 10 | 8 Jun 1996 | USA | v Hong Kong | 12 Apr 1998 | USA | v Spain |
| PT Eloff | 10 | 27 May 2000 | USA | v Japan | 23 May 2001 | USA | v Argentina |
| S LaValla | 9 | 5 Jun 2010 | USA | v Russia | 27 Sep 2011 | USA | v Italy |
| E Fry | 9 | 8 Jun 2011 | USA | v Tonga | 23 Jun 2012 | USA | v Italy |
| DJ Lyle | 8 | 5 Nov 1994 | USA | v Ireland | 29 Jun 1996 | USA | v Hong Kong |
| J Waasdorp | 8 | 17 May 2003 | USA | v Japan | 30 May 2004 | USA | v Russia |
| F Viljoen | 8 | 30 May 2004 | USA | v Russia | 4 Jun 2005 | USA | v Wales |
| TS Clever | 8 | 23 Aug 2003 | USA | v Argentina | 7 Jun 2006 | USA | v NZ Maori |
| P Farner | 7 | 15 May 1999 | USA | v Tonga | 10 Jun 2000 | USA | v Ireland |
| CE Erskine | 7 | 12 Aug 2006 | USA | v Canada | 30 Sep 2007 | USA | v South Africa |
| G Lambert | 6 | 6 Jun 1981 | USA | v Canada | 16 Nov 1985 | USA | v Canada |
| B Warhurst | 6 | 11 Jun 1983 | USA | v Canada | 31 May 1986 | USA | v Japan |
| RB Nelson | 6 | 11 Jun 1983 | USA | v Canada | 10 May 1987 | USA | v Canada |
| KA Khasigian | 6 | 15 Aug 1998 | USA | v Argentina | 14 Oct 1999 | USA | v Australia |
| LE Stanfill | 6 | 25 May 2005 | USA | v Canada | 8 Sep 2007 | USA | v England |
| CT Wyles | 6 | 18 May 2007 | USA | v England A | 26 Sep 2007 | USA | v Samoa |
| B Doyle | 6 | 7 Jun 2008 | USA | v England A | 23 Jun 2012 | USA | v Italy |
| J Grobler | 5 | 14 Sep 1996 | USA | v Argentina | 25 May 1997 | USA | v Japan |
| KS Schubert | 5 | 27 May 2000 | USA | v Japan | 7 Jul 2000 | USA | v Tonga |
| MS MacDonald | 5 | 30 Jun 2000 | USA | v Fiji | 16 Jun 2001 | USA | v England |
| KM Kjar | 5 | 23 May 2001 | USA | v Argentina | 13 Jul 2002 | USA | v Canada |
| C Hodgson | 5 | 22 Jun 2002 | USA | v Scotland | 12 Apr 2003 | USA | v Spain |
| R Helu | 4 | 6 Jun 1981 | USA | v Canada | 19 Jun 1982 | USA | v England XV |
| PW Johnson | 4 | 10 May 1987 | USA | v Canada | 14 Nov 1987 | USA | v Canada |
| MA Williams | 4 | 7 Nov 1987 | USA | v Wales | 17 Sep 1988 | USA | v Romania |
| AM Ridnell | 4 | 31 May 1987 | USA | v Australia | 25 Sep 1988 | USA | v Russia |
| J Clayton | 4 | 19 Jun 1999 | USA | v Canada | 27 May 2000 | USA | v Japan |
| JS Naivalu | 4 | 15 Jul 2000 | USA | v Samoa | 19 May 2001 | USA | v Canada |
| PL Emerick | 4 | 27 Apr 2003 | USA | v Spain | 27 Aug 2003 | USA | v Canada |
| J van der Giessen | 4 | 7 Jun 2008 | USA | v England A | 16 Nov 2008 | USA | v Japan |
| JR Gagiano | 4 | 8 Nov 2008 | USA | v Uruguay | 31 May 2009 | USA | v Ireland |
| JL Sifa | 4 | 8 Nov 2008 | USA | v Uruguay | 6 Jun 2009 | USA | v Wales |
| JD Paterson | 4 | 21 Aug 2011 | USA | v Japan | 27 Sep 2011 | USA | v Italy |
| Records include the following current or recent matches: |
|
United States of America v Italy at Houston, Jun 23, 2012 [10-30 FT] |
|
United States of America v Georgia at Glendale, Jun 16, 2012 [36-20 FT] |
|
United States of America v Canada at Glendale, 2nd Test, Aug 13, 2011 [7-27 FT] |
